Traditional innerspring mattresses, which are made primarily of coils without many other layers, were a staple sleep product for decades. Modern innerspring models often include a comfort system for more balanced conforming and support. This makes them very similar to hybrids, which are mattresses made up of both coils and comfort layers. Despite the changes, the updated innerspring design still provides many of the benefits of traditional innersprings, including breathability, affordability, edge support, and responsiveness.
Based on the results of our hands-on mattress tests, we’ll share our top picks for the best innerspring mattress, including discussing the different types of coils, how much you should expect to pay, and the average lifespan of an innerspring model.
Find Your Perfect Mattress
We know mattresses work differently for different types of sleepers. Use the filters below to help narrow down your options for your best bed.
Read on to see why the following five options made our top picks list of 2024’s best innerspring mattresses.
Sleep Doctor’s Picks
Best Overall
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
Sleep Doctor’s Review
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is versatile, affordable, and a strong performer in several key testing areas such as temperature control and pressure relief. You can choose from three firmness levels based on your body type and primary sleep position.
Buy From Brooklyn Bedding
Couples
Medium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Bouncy, Supportive Surface
Great Value
Pros
- Available in three firmness levels
- Contouring comfort system relieves pressure
- Budget-friendly without sacrificing durability
Cons
- Foam layers may hinder movements across the surface
- Motion isolation and pressure relief limited in firmer models
Why We Like It
The Brooklyn Signature Hybrid comes in three firmness levels: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (8). We found that these options meet the needs of most sleep positions and body types, and the accessible price-point gives the mattress broad appeal.
Its comfort system starts with a layer of highly responsive gel-infused TitanFlex polyfoam that hugs your body without taking away from the springy feel. Our testers felt that it provided good cushioning without the sometimes overly plush feel of memory foam. We also noted that the VariFlex polyfoam transition layer underneath provided additional support, distributing weight evenly across the bed’s surface to limit sinking.
In the core, 8 inches of Ascension pocketed coils supported by a base layer of high-density polyfoam offer responsive support. Pocketed coils move independently of each other, which makes for better contouring and motion isolation. In our tests, we found that these coils responded well to movement without transferring it across the mattress. The high-caliber coils reinforcing the perimeter of the mattress also allowed most of our testers to easily get into and out of bed.
How Does It Feel?
Overall, our testers reported that all three firmness levels of the Brooklyn Signature Hybrid provided good pressure relief without causing them to sink too far into the bed. They were able to change positions easily, indicating that this mattress would work well for active sleepers. We also found that the combination of relatively breathable foam and coils encourages airflow, making this mattress a good option for hot sleepers.
The side sleepers on our team preferred the medium soft and medium firm options for their pressure relief and motion isolation. Back and stomach sleepers liked the medium firm and firm options best. After reviewing all the feedback, we determined that the medium firm option offers nearly universal support to different sleep styles and works especially well for couples.
Best Value
Real Bed
Sleep Doctor’s Review
The Real Bed’s latex hybrid design offers considerable bounce, robust support, and a decent lifespan — all at an approachable sticker price. Breathable cover and comfort layer components also allow the mattress to sleep exceptionally cool throughout the year.
Buy From Real Bed
Hot Sleepers
Firm (7)
Bouncy, Supportive Surface
Great Value
Pros
- Firm surface relieves pressure while enabling active sleeping and sex
- Designed to sleep cool
- Natural materials
Cons
- Too responsive to isolate much motion transfer
- Minimal contouring and cushioning for most side sleepers
Why We Like It
Traditionally, innerspring mattresses aren’t known for excelling at pressure relief because they tend to lack robust comfort layers. However, the Real Bed, a firm (7) hybrid model, finds a balance between the sturdiness of an innerspring and the pressure relief of a plush comfort system.
Wrapped in a breathable GOTS-certified organic cotton cover, the mattress’ comfort system includes rayon, wool, and natural latex. Our testers found that this responsive combination created a buoyant feel and prevented excessive sinkage while still conforming around pressure-prone areas.
How Does It Feel?
One of the ways the Real Bed provides good pressure relief is by using pocketed coils. These coils are individually wrapped and compress independently in response to your weight. They also give the bed a bouncy feel and strengthen the edges. Additional layers of wool, latex, and rayon support the coil system.
Our temperature control tests, which include both tracking temperature and getting feedback from testers, showed that the Real Bed’s breathable materials keep heat from building up. This makes it a good choice for hot sleepers.
The Real Bed’s firm feel and subtle conforming worked best for our back and stomach sleepers, especially those over 230 pounds.
Most Comfortable
Avocado Green Mattress
Sleep Doctor’s Review
Available as a firmer standard model or a gentler Euro-top design, the Avocado Green maintains even support for most sleepers thanks to its responsive latex comfort layer and zoned coil system. All U.S. orders include a generous 365-night sleep trial.
Buy From Avocado
Back Sleepers
Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Responsive Latex
Fair Value
Pros
- Certified organic materials
- Zoned coils for targeted support
- Responsive surface for sex and active sleepers
Cons
- Responsive latex hybrid design offers minimal motion isolation
- Sleepers under 130 pounds may not receive enough cushioning
Why We Like It
The Avocado Green Mattress is the mainstay of Avocado’s mattress line, which is known for using primarily sustainable products. It includes GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton and GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex in its comfortably supportive design. Nearly all of our testers across body types and sleep styles reported that the Avocado Green Mattress provided a good balance of conforming pressure relief and solid support.
Underneath the breathable organic cotton cover, the comfort system includes a combination of organic wool and Dunlop latex that we found reduces pressure without hugging the body too closely. The moisture-wicking wool is designed to keep you cool and dry, and our temperature tests confirmed that the mattress surface doesn’t retain significant heat.
Coils are another important part of a hybrid mattress’ comfort system. The number, type, and arrangement can determine how well a mattress supports your body and regulates temperature. Sporting a support core that features up to 1,414 tempered steel coils, the Avocado Green impressed our testers with its stability and efficient airflow. The coils are arranged in five ergonomic zones with narrower coils in the edges and center of the bed for extra support. A final base layer of Dunlop latex supports the coils as they compress.
How Does It Feel?
Between the medium firm (6) pillow-top version and the standard firm (7) option, we found that the Avocado Green Mattress can support virtually any sleep position and body type. The pillow-top version particularly appealed to our side sleepers, while stomach sleepers preferred the firm option. Back sleepers generally enjoyed both versions equally.
Our motion isolation tests indicated that the springy surface would be excellent for both sex and frequent changes in sleep position while still isolating motion relatively well. Additionally, we found that the mattress produces minimal off-gassing odors, making it a good choice if you’re sensitive to the “new bed smell.”
The Avocado Green Mattress is GREENGUARD Gold certified for emission standards. Many of its materials also hold OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, verifying that they have been independently tested for a variety of harmful substances.
Best for Side Sleepers
Casper Original Hybrid
Sleep Doctor’s Review
The Casper Original Hybrid pairs adaptive foam with zoned support layers to create a medium (5), well-balanced feel for people weighing up to 230 pounds — side sleepers in particular. The mattress also isolates more motion and alleviates more pressure than the average innerspring model.
Buy From Casper
Side Sleepers
Medium (5)
Plush, Supportive Surface
Good Value
Pros
- Patented AirScape polyfoam engineered for air circulation
- Balanced contouring and bounce
- Zoned memory foam designed to improve sleep posture
Cons
- Back and stomach sleepers may sink excessively
- Perimeter lacks stability when bearing weight
Why We Like It
Side sleepers usually need a mattress that contours to the body and relieves pressure at trouble spots, such as the shoulders and hips. The side sleepers on our team found that the medium (5) Casper Original Hybrid provides both of these things while also focusing on keeping you cool as you sleep.
The Casper Original Hybrid’s cover contains recycled polyester, upcycled cotton, rayon, and lycra. The comfort system starts with AirScape polyfoam, which contains thousands of perforations to boost airflow. Our temperature control tests showed that there was very little heat buildup, and we also found that the mattress did a great job of easing pressure.
Underneath the Airscape polyfoam, a layer of memory foam enhances the contouring, and zoning adds ergonomic support. Zoning means that the foam layer is firmer in some places and softer in others so it can better support specific areas of the body–an important factor for side sleepers. Finally, a support core of pocketed coils bolsters the surface and adds bounce. Polyfoam wraps around the outside of the coil system to reinforce the edge.
How Does It Feel?
The Casper Original Hybrid’s combination of cradling and support makes it a great option for side and back sleepers of all body types. Most of our testers who were stomach sleepers under 230 pounds also felt they received sufficient support.
The mattress’ balance of motion isolation, edge support, and bounce makes it a popular option for couples. Our partner tests showed that sleepers can easily move around without disturbing each other, and they had very little trouble getting into and out of the bed.
The Casper Original Hybrid is a good fit for side sleepers who need a balance of pressure relief and temperature control. It’s also likely to suit couples who want the additional benefit of easy movement.
Best for Couples
Lulu Hybrid
Sleep Doctor’s Review
The Lulu Hybrid has a balanced medium firm (6) feel, sturdy perimeter, and a thick foam comfort layer to absorb motion — all important attributes for co-sleepers. Our team also enjoyed the hybrid’s cooling cover that captures and releases heat on contact, resulting in a surface that feels cool at all times.
Buy From Lulu
Couples
Medium Firm (6)
Bouncy, Supportive Surface
Fair Value
Pros
- Memory foam hybrid design offers even contouring and sturdy support
- Proprietary ION cover engineered to dissipate heat and promote physical recovery
- Pocketed coils are reinforced along the perimeter to limit sinkage
Cons
- Not enough cushioning for most side sleepers
- Foam layers may sink and hinder surface movements
Why We Like It
If you and your partner are in the market for a new mattress, the Lulu Hybrid checks a lot of boxes for couples. The comfort layer is composed of memory foam that absorbs movement well, significantly reducing the amount of transfer you feel when your sleep partner moves in bed, and vice versa.
Sturdy pocketed coils make up the support core. The coils are reinforced along the perimeter to stabilize the edges. This allows both of you to use the entire bed for sleep or sex, rather than feeling confined to the middle. A base layer of high-density polyfoam provides additional reinforcement.
How Does It Feel
A notable feature of the Lulu Hybrid is its cover made of proprietary ION fabric. This innovative material is designed to promote circulation and muscle recovery, allowing you to wake up each morning feeling well-rested. ION fabric also has heat-dissipating properties to maintain a cool, comfortable surface.
The Lulu Hybrid is considered medium firm (6). After testing the mattress, we’ve determined its supportive, moderately contouring design is best suited to side sleepers weighing more than 230 pounds, and back and stomach sleepers weighing at least 130 pounds.
Why You Should Trust Us
Leveraging our vast knowledge and experience in the sleep product industry, we carefully analyze each product we review to provide an unbiased assessment.
Our goal is to help you choose the right sleep products for your needs, lifestyle, and budget. To that end, we perform a variety of in-depth tests that look at factors such as motion isolation, temperature regulation, and pressure relief. In addition to our quantitative research, we rely on feedback from testers of varying body types and position preferences to get a clear idea of how the same mattress performs for different individuals.
One thing you can count on with innerspring mattresses is support. The amount of support will vary depending on the materials and thickness of the comfort layers, but innersprings are a good place to start if you need a certain amount of sturdiness and responsiveness from your mattress.
